The Leading Global Provider of Audit Analytics Technology

The Leading Global Provider of Audit Analytics Technology ACL Solutions Update Virginia User’s Group Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. Steve Biskie CPA, CITP, CISA Best Practices Program Director, steve_biskie@acl. com

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. Why Continuous? § Provide management with ability to investigate and resolve problems before they escalate – minimizing losses and containing costs § Improve ability to quantify risk (both likelihood and impact) § Establish a strong tone-at-the-top § Leverage automation power required for CA/CM to: – Increase assurance through 100% testing of all transactions – Reduce time spent on control testing, allowing resources to focus on control improvement – Enhance monitoring consistency across the enterprise, reducing dependency on people

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. Continuous Auditing and Monitoring: Where are we? Where are we going? § ACL has 11, 000+ user organizations globally (85% of Fortune 500) § Numerous ACL user organizations have independently developed CA/CM applications using built-in ACL scripting and dialogs § ACL first introduced packaged CM application in 2001 – Largest implementation of CCM over P 2 P in the world: 2008 § ACL Audit. Exchange released in May, 2008 – managed analytic platform for audit

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. Enterprise Controls Monitoring at Siemens § Largest P 2 P transaction monitoring project in the world – All corporate entities (currently 900+) – 275 different data sources & applications – All Purchase to Pay transactions (20 -40 Million transactions/day) § Exceptions: workflow process – Process managed by entity business owners – Unresolved exceptions automatically escalated through multiple CFO levels

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. ACL CCM Product Suite § Browser-based interface: – – Manage Continuous Monitoring process Security and Administration Manage test parameters View, report and manage exceptions

The Leading Global Provider of Audit Analytics Technology Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd.

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. Organized by business process and

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. Payment tests results

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. Analytic test description Specific test

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. Parameters can be changed to include or exclude new values into the analytics for future CCM tests. All changes are logged and restricted to only authorized users.

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. 6+ years of CCM: What we learned § Design differences despite similar tests § Differing reporting requirements across organization § Tremendous flexibility required by complex organizations § Cross-departmental project challenges § Test flexibility and adaptability needs increase as organizations learn more about their own processes § Strong need for ad-hoc analytic capabilities along with pre-defined CCM tests

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. Continuum of Audit Analytics § One-off analysis and testing § Automated analyses and tests § Managed and deployed from a central environment § Continual execution of automated audit and monitoring tests to identify errors, fraud anomalies on a timely basis 24 7 365 ad hoc repetitiv e continuo us

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. nabling the Continuum of Audit Analytics A MANAGED ANALYTICS PLATFORM for AUDIT Secure controlled access to data Configuration, automation and scheduling of tests Management of tests, documentation, findings, logs, workflow One common platform 24 7 365 ad hoc repetitiv e continuo us

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. Extending Analytics Value Across the Department ACL Audit. Exchange Data Specialists Needs § Broad, direct data access § Data preparation & management § Maintain data security § Preserve network efficiency CREATE Auditors / Analysts Needs Auditors, Audit Management & Audit Executives Needs § Ad hoc query § Broader audit coverage § Scripting & script management § Ability to review analytic findings across the team & against audit plan objectives § Audit-specific functions § Ability to share selected results with management across the enterprise (Audit Committee, Finance, Risk Compliance, etc. ) § Automation of audit tests § Implement continuous auditing & monitoring § Comprehensive audit trail CONSUME REVIEW

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. Populating and Refreshing the Audit Data Repository ETL for ACL Audit. Exchange includes: § Flat files § Delimited § ODBC - compliant data sources § Sybase § SQL § Informix § Oracle § d. Base § Microsoft Access § Simple XML Connectors for Complex Databases include: § DB 2 § Teradata § IMS for z/OS § VSAM for z/OS § ADABAS for z/OS Connectors for ERP Systems include: § Oracle e-Business Suite § People. Soft Enterprise § SAP ERP, BW, CRM Connectors for Complex Data include: With a Complex Data Exchange, you can reach: § PDF § Spreadsheet data § Report (Print) files § Complex XML § XBRL § SAP Private file formats Add-ons to the Complex Data Exchange include format libraries for: § SWIFT § HIPAA § HL 7

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. Continuous Auditing and Monitoring: Implementation Options § Option 1: Buy a pre-packaged CCM application § Option 2: Implement ACL’s Audit. Exchange, and incrementally build a continuous platform using internal capabilities – Focus on a handful of analytics in high-value areas – Use success and $ savings from these results to fund future expansion – Rely primarily on internal experience § Option 3: Kick-start an ACL’s Audit. Exchange continuous program with a comprehensive program of training, consulting and coaching – Focus on high-risk business cycles – Use ACL consulting to build initial analytics, while coaching internal employees to build and maintain subsequent improvements

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. B R E A K

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. Implementation Observations § § Planning

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. Steve Biskie CPA, CITP, CISA

ACL Services Ltd. Copyright © 2008 ACL Services Ltd. Why ACL vs. other tools? § Designed for Audit: Built-in audit-specific functions § Assurance: Logs record every audit activity for QA § Independence: Non-technical auditors can perform analysis with limited reliance on IT personnel § Data Integrity: Read-only tool cannot change data § Efficiency: Quickly process millions of records § Breadth: Read data from practically any source § Flexibility – Change and maintain tests quickly with limited vendor reliance § Recruiting: Over 200, 000 auditors use ACL