Ten Years of Investigation Irrefutable Evidence Organ Harvesting on Falun Gong Practitioners A State Organized Crime in China 1
Outline I. State Organized Crime: Order from the top II. Organ Transplants Exploded after 1999 III. Witnesses to Live Organ Harvesting IV. Organ Harvesting Rampant in China V. A Massive Live Organ Pool VI. Sources of organs & death row VII. Organ Transplants: Kill-on-Demand VIII. Falun Gong practitioners are victims of organ harvesting Appendix Note: Data for this presentation all come from WOGIPF. 2
I. State Organized Crime • The CCP Head Jiang Zemin Ordered to Genocide Falun Gong Practitioners • Live Organ Harvesting Mechanism • Top Officials Gave Evidence Against Jiang • Doctors, Legal Systems, Police and Military Collaborate in the Crime 3
CCP Head Jiang Zeming Initiated Persecution of Falun Gong 1. Former Chinese president JIANG Zemin gave the genocide order of Falun Gong practitioners: “ruin their reputation, destroy them financially, and eradicate them physically. ” 2. As of Aug 14, 2016, Minghui website gave records of 4, 018 known Falun Gong practitioners who were persecuted to death in over 30 provinces and districts. 4
Live Organ Harvesting Mechanism in China CCP Head Jiang Zemin Gave genocide order Central and local Political and Legal Affairs Commissions, the “ 610” Offices and police mass arrest and torture Falun Gong practitioners Military, Police, Judiciary system, Hospitals, and governments across the country collaborate to take part in Live organ harvesting 5
High-Ranking Officials & Specialists: Jiang Zemin ordered to extract organs from Falun Gong practitioners Witness 1. Bai Shuzhong, Former Minister of Health for the Chinese People’s Liberation Army’s (PLA) General Logistics Department Witness 2. Bo Xilai, then-minister of commerce Witness 3. Tan Yunshan, chief physician from the Liver Pathological Department at the Affiliated Zhongshan Hospital of Fudan University Witness 4. Dr. Gong of the second ward of the Cardiothoracic Surgery Department of the Affiliated Tongji Hospital of Huazhong University of Science and Technology 6
Jiang Zemin ordered to extract organs from Falun Gong practitioners Witness 1: Bai Shuzhong Sept. 30, 2014, WOIPFG Investigator called Bai, disguised as special investigator from Bo Xilai’s case: Bai Shuzhong Former Minister of Health for PLA General Logistics Dept 1998 -2004 Bai Shuzhong: Back then it was Chairman Jiang. There was an order, a sort of instruction, which said to carry out such things, organ transplantation. That is to say, it was not only the military that was doing kidney transplants. http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 7
Jiang Zemin ordered to extract organs from Falun Gong practitioners Witness 2: Bo Xilai On Sept. 13, 2006, on a state visit to Hamburg, Germany while accompanying premier Wen Jiabo, then Minister of Commerce Bo Xilai was being investigated by an investigator, disguised as First Secretary from the Chinese Embassy in Germany. Bo Xilai Former Governor of Liaoning; Former Secretary of Municipal Party Committee of Chongqing; Member of the CCP Central Committee 3/15/2018 Investigator: “That is, when you were the governor of Liaoning Province, …that is to say, regarding the matter of live organ harvesting of Falun Gong (practitioners), was that your order or Jiang Zemin’s order? ” Bo: “President Jiang’s!” http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 8
Jiang Zemin ordered to extract organs from Falun Gong practitioners Witness 3: Vice Premier Phone recording of Politburo Standing Committee Member Zhang Gaoli 调查员：你好！江泽民同志有几句话让我转告你。说最近有上万名法轮功习练者向最高检查院控 告江泽民同志，说追究江泽民同志下令摘取几百万法轮功学员器官的责任，所以江泽民同志很担 忧这个事，他希望呢…… 张高丽：啊。 调查员：他希望你呢在政治局討论的时候，一定要阻止追究这件事。 张高丽：好。 调查员：你能做到吗？ 张高丽：好，好，好。 Zhang Gaoli Vice Premier of the State Council, Politburo Standing Committee Member Investigator: Hello, Comrade Jiang Zemin has a few words to pass to you. Recently thousands of Falun Gong practitioners are suing Comrade Jiang Zemin to the Superieum Court for he had ordered to organ harvest millions of Falun Gong practitioners. So he much worries about it. He hopes. . Zhang Gaoli: Oh. Investigator: He hopes that you will block pursuing this case at the Polibureau meeting. Zhang Gaoli: Sure. Investigator: Can you do it? Zhang Gaoli: Sure, sure. WOIPFG Archive: Zhang Gaoli does not deny that millions of Falun Gong practitioners have fallen victims to organ harvesting http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org/node/48177 9
Evidences 4 -6: Central Political and Legislative Affairs Committee (PLAC) and the 610 System are directly involved in the organ harvesting crimes Zhou Benshun——The secretary-general of the Central PLAC, former Secretary of Hebei Party Committee Zhou Benshun: “Such things as live organ harvesting from Falun Gong practitioners in our country, it does exist in our country. ” Wei Jianrong — Former vice director of Central PLAC Office Investigator: meaning organ harvesting of living Falun Gong practitioners started very early? Wei Jianrong: “Yes, yes, started a long time ago. ” Tang Junjie — Former Deputy Secretary of PLAC in Liaoning Province Investigator: Did Bo Xilai give any order in extracting organs from Falun Gong practitioners and use them for transplant operations? Tang Junjie: “I was asked to be in charge of this task. Party Central Committee is actually paying close attention to this. ” “It was mainly the standing committee which held meetings and discussed this. ” 10
Military, police, judiciary and legal systems and hospitals involved in live organ harvesting 1. Testimony from an armed guard who is an eyewitness of live organ harvesting 2. Chen Qiang - The PLA No. 307 Hospital in Fengtai, Beijing 3. Intermediate People’s Court of Jinzhou 4. Chen Rongshan - Department of Urology at the PLA No. 205 Hospital in Jinzhou 5. Zhongshan Hospital Affiliated with Fudan University in Shanghai： “What we have here all belong to this type (Falun Gong). ” 7. Doctor Lu Guoping - Guangxi Nationalities Hospital 11
Outline I. State Organized Crime: Order from the top II. Organ Transplants Exploded after 1999 III. Witnesses to Live Organ Harvesting IV. Organ Harvesting Rampant in China V. A Massive Live Organ Pool VI. Sources of organs & death row VII. Organ Transplants: Kill-on-Demand VIII. Falun Gong practitioners are victims of organ harvesting Appendix 12
II. Organ Transplants Exploded after 1999 • • • Liver transplant hospitals up 20 times Liver transplant operations up 180 times Liver transplants up 436 times in 2006 vs. 1999 One hospital transplanted 4, 000 organs, more than the whole country of Germany China once had 1, 000 transplant hospitals 13
Since the Persecution in 1999 Liver Transplant Hospitals Increased 20 -fold 500 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 1998 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 2006 14
Liver Transplants up 180 Times 99 -06 v. s 91 -98 1991 -1998 1999 -2006 1. 《中国肝移植注册网》2006/06/24 (HKT 10: 51: 54) http: //cltr. org/ 2. 2010年 3月黄洁夫在马德里发布的所谓中国器官移植总数量 78 14, 085 15
China’s Annual Liver Transplants Before and After the Persecution in 1999 1977 -98 # of Years 1991 -99 1999 -2006 20 8 2006 8 1 Transplants 135 78 85 14, 0 4, 231 Annual Average Transplants 6. 7 9. 7 1, 760 4, 231 1 180 436 Comparison before & after 1999 Up 436 times in 2006 vs. 1999 Source: China Liver Transplant Registration site: 2006/06/24 (HKT 10: 51: 54) http: //cltr. org/ WOIPFG Archive: http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org/sites/default/files/report/2015/59389_11. png http: //www. upholdjustice. org/sites/default/files/report/2015/325 -11. png 16 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org
Beijing University People’s Hospital: 4, 000 Liver & Renal Transplants Performed in a Year Before 2010 One Hospital Transplanted More Than the Whole Germany China Economic Weekly: Dr. ZHU Jiye, President of Beijing University Organ Transplant Institute & Director of Hepatobiliary Surgery in Beijing University People’s Hospital, said in an interview with China Economic Weekly: “…Our hospital made 4, 000 liver and renal transplants within a year before 2010, such organs are all from death penalty prisoners. ” 17
Another Hospital Official Data Tianjin First Central Hospital’s Organ Transplants Liver Kidney Sources: Baike. com, Organ Tourism: http: //www. baike. com/wiki/%E 5%99%A 8%E 5%AE%98%E 7%A 7%BB%E 6%A 4%8 D%E 6%97%85%E 6%B 8 WOIPFG archive: http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org/cn/images/nationalcriminalreports/17. png October 10, 2008, “Chronicles of Events at the Tianjin First Central Hospital”: http: //www. transplantation. org. cn/ZTian. Jin. Di. Yi. Zhong. Xin. Yi. Yuan. Kuai. Xun/2008 -10/3093. htm January 5, 2006, ” 2005 Year-end Conference at the Tianjin First Central Hospital”: http: //www. ootc. net/Home. Page/File. Doc. Detail. aspx? fileno=494 18
Actual Organ Transplants Over 10 Times of Official Figures • Above mentioned are only official published numbers. • WOIPF’s investigation shows actual organ transplants are more than ten times as much. • The next slide lists official numbers, along with WOIPF’s low and high estimates. 19
Actual Organ Transplants Over 10 Times of Official Figures 96 hospitals are found to perform over 1000 transplants/year. The average is around 2000 -3000 cases/year. 20
Official People’s Daily Online Reported: 1000 Transplant Hospitals In 2015: Ye Qi-fa, acting chairman of China Organ Procurement Organization said, since the Regulations on Human Organ Transplantation were issued in 2007, the number of medical facilities in China that performed transplant operations dropped dramatically from 1000 to 160. By July 10, 2016, WOIPFG’s investigation indicated that as many as 9, 519 medical personnel from 891 hospitals in China were suspected of engaging in living organ transplants. 21
Outline I. State Organized Crime: Order from the top II. Organ Transplants Exploded after 1999 III. Witnesses to Live Organ Harvesting IV. Organ Harvesting Rampant in China V. A Massive Live Organ Pool VI. Sources of organs & death row VII. Organ Transplants: Kill-on-Demand VIII. Falun Gong practitioners are victims of organ harvesting Appendix 22
III. Witnesses to Organ Harvesting 1. Annie & Peter exposed Sujiatun death-camp 2. Senior military doctor revealed live organ banks 3. Imprisoned Falun Gong practitioners in deathcamps are victims of organ harvesting in China. 4. Testimony of an armed guard in the live organ transplant operation room 5. Police admitted killing and selling Falun Gong practitioner’s organs 23
The Appalling News: Eyewitnesses Spoke Out in 2006 In March 2006, the wife of a surgeon who operated at a thrombosis hospital in Sujiatun, Shenyang, exposed to the Epoch Times the crimes of CCP harvesting organs from living Falun practitioners Wife of a surgeon exposing facts of organ harvesting in Washington D. C. 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 24
Annie & Peter Exposed Sujiatun Death-camp Annie’s ex-husband extracted 2, 000 corneas between 2001 and 2003. Nobody ever came out alive. Many of the 6, 000 Falun Gong practitioners there died after their kidneys, corneas, skins had been extracted. Their bodies were exterminated. Now still there about 2, 000 Falun Gong practitioners in the hospital. I worry the authorities would distinguish evidence and kill the witnesses. 25
Senior Military Doctor Revealed Organ Harvesting Live Organ Bank Sujiatun is only one of 36 death-camps in China. The largest camp is in Jilin. Its code number is 672 -S, imprisoning over 120, 000 Falun Gong practitioners. 26
Testimony of an Armed Guard Who Eyewitnessed Live Organ Harvesting Operation Date: April 9, 2002, Time: The operation began at 5: 00 pm, ended at 8: 00 pm Location: in a surgery room on the 15 th floor of the General Hospital of Shenyang Military Region The guard saw: A female Falun Gong practitioner in her 30 s (she was a teacher)，covered with wounds and scars over her entire body, the result of a week of torture, rape, and force-feeding. Two military doctors, without applying any anesthesia, extracted her heart, kidneys and other organs while she remained fully conscious, cold-bloodedly killing her in the process. 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 27
活摘現場持槍警衛證詞 2002年 4月9日，在瀋陽軍區總醫院 15樓的一間手術室內，證人 持槍警衛，親眼看到兩個軍醫（其中一名軍官證號碼 0106069） 將一名30多歲的修鍊法輪功的中學女教師，在沒打麻藥的情況下， 活生生地摘取了她的心、肝、腎器官。在此之前，女教師遭受了 一個月的嚴刑拷打、侮辱和強暴。 证人：以后如果我还活着的话，你就帮我转载这些东西。 调查员：好，我答应你。 证人：如果我要是死了，你就找别人，或者打听我这个……, 或者是把我这 个事迹做成一个文章，我倒是不是为了让他们知道我，为了让更多的我出 来，敢于说真话。 …… 调查员：哪个时间你还没有告诉我？ 证人： 2002年 4月9日。 调查员： 4月9日？ 证人：对 4月9日下午5点开始解剖，时间进行了3个小时。之前已经连续一 28 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 28 个月了。
Police Zhu Jiabin Admitted to Harvesting and “Selling” Organs From January to June 2016, WOIPFG’s recording of the killer: Zhu Jiabin, the head of the general department of the CCP’s“ 610 Office” in Mudanjiang City, Heilongjiang Province, admitted in a high-profile way to live organ harvesting Falun Gong practitioner Gao Yixi. Sounding to be unscrupulous and emboldened in the knowledge of being backed up, he said that he had “sold” Gao’s organs. Investigator: You carved out his organs, and (you think) you can get away with it? Zhu Jiabin… Zhu Jiabin: Sold them! Investigator: Ah? Zhu Jiabin: All sold, they were all sold. 2016 Latest WOIPFG report: http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org/node/67047 29
Outline I. State Organized Crime: Order from the top II. Organ Transplants Exploded after 1999 III. Witnesses to Live Organ Harvesting IV. Organ Harvesting Rampant in China V. A Massive Live Organ Pool VI. Sources of organs & death row VII. Organ Transplants: Kill-on-Demand VIII. Falun Gong practitioners are victims of organ harvesting Appendix 30
IV. Organ Harvesting Rampant in China • Hard evidence collected from all walks of life • Organ Transplant Hospitals in all provinces of China • Medical research papers detailed the operation of live organ harvesting procedure • Surgeons boast organ transplant figures • Marketing and sales promotion • Hospitals attract twenty-country organ tourists • Smuggling Falun Gong practitioners’ organs into Israel http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 31
Evidence from All Walks of Life Evidence obtained from: • Top state level officials; • 5 members of the standing committee of the Politburo; • 1 vice chairman of the CCP’s Central Military Commission; • 1 Central Military Commission member; • 1 former defense minister, • 1 former Minister of Health, General Logistics Depart. of the PLA. • 9, 519 transplant doctors • 891 hospitals with organ transplant centers • Hundreds of thousands of public media reports, medical papers, cached hospital webpages • Official websites of Chinese government, media, court, • Direct phone interview recordings http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 32
China’s Organ Transplant Hospitals • • • Hospitals in all provinces in China Almost all tertiary hospitals in China (891 out of 1082) Hospital types: general hospitals, military hospitals, police hospitals, traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) hospitals, forensic hospitals, children’s hospitals, and specialist hospitals. 33
The Medical Paper Records the Operation of a Live Organ Harvesting A medical paper published by Wu Jian and other physicians from Kunming Yan’an Hospital describes the procedure of a heart extraction： The surgical procedure: After the donor (organ provider) entered the operating room, conventional anesthesia and endotracheal intubation procedures were administered; intravenous administration of 1 g methylprednisolone and heparin (3 mg/Kg) was given to the organ provider. After the anesthesia began taking effect, routine draping procedure was followed using sterile towels. Incision was made in the center and into the chest swiftly using routine surgery procedures. 34
Analysis: The Medical Papers Leaks Proofs of Live Organ Harvesting 1. The donor was a living person, because only living people would need anesthesia and intubation. 2. The donor was conscious, as according to the description of the surgical procedure, “after the anesthesia began taking effect, routine draping procedure was followed using sterile towels. ” This record indicates that the person had physiological signs (nerve sensory functions and reflexes) to check, to determine whether the anesthesia was effective. 3. The donor had spontaneous breathing, because anesthesia and routine tracheal intubation only took place after the donor entered the operating room. That is to say, before entering the room, he or she could breathe on his or her own without intubation. 4. The organ provider was not brain-dead or in a deep coma, if so, he or she would have required endotracheal intubation and intravenous fluids before entering the room to maintain breathing and heartbeat. 5. The fact that they can write down the murder process and publish it in a medical paper shows that killing has become their routine work, and that they are quite reckless. It also reflects the severity of live organ harvesting by the CCP. 35
Recording: Surgeons’ Words “Ample supply, we transplanted 6 kidneys today. ” “… come over, both liver and kidney can be transplanted today. ” “Next Monday has a live organ, 25 -30 years old. ” We have organs this week, & next week… Did 100 kidneys a year, come Sat. or Sun. ” 36
Experts: China’s Liver Transplants More than 3 Times of Official Data 1) On May 11, 2011, transplant specialist Wu Mengchao said: At present, China performs the most liver transplants in the world. 2) The U. S. performs 6, 000 liver transplants a year. So China performed more than 6, 000, yet Chinese government reported only 2, 000+ liver cases for all hospitals after 2010. 3) Accordingly, China’s liver transplants are more than 6, 000 ----3 times more than the official number. WU Mengchao Director, Eastern Hepatobiliary Hospital, Second Military Medical University; Deputy Chief, Team of Medical Specialists, PLA General Logistics; Deputy Director, Member, Medical Science and Technology Committee, PLA; Jiang Zemin met with Wu 5 times, and personally awarded him the title of “Exemplary Medical Specialist” and a firstclass medal. Source: Xinhuanet interview of Wu Meng-chao, May 11, 2011 37
Experts: Liver Transplants Increased 30 Times in 6 Years 2）He Xiaoshun: “The number of liver transplants nationwide in 2000 was 10 times that of 1999, and by 2005 the number had tripled since 2000” That is a 30 -times increase in 6 years. Source: Phoenix Magazine Network published an article titled “The Inside Story of Human Organ Trading in China” on November 5, 2013. 38
Experts: China’s Organ Transplants Exceed Published Data 3）Surgeon Huang Jiefu himself performed over 500 liver transplants in 2012, but only one was from a donor. Huang Jiefu Chairman, National Organ Donation and Transplantation Committee; Deputy Director, Central Health Committee; Former Minister of Health, mainly in charge of organ transplant 2002 -present, liver transplant surgeon at Peking Union Medical College Hospital Huang Jiefu said: “I performed over 500 liver transplants last year (2012). Last November the one that I did in Guangzhou was the first standard citizen donation in China. Former President of Sun Yat-sen University; Director, Organ Transplant Center 39
Media reports validate the large scale of transplants performed 1. China Economic Weekly: Peking University People’s Hospital performed 4, 000 liver and kidney transplants within a year. Sources: Xinhuanet, March 9, 2013 2. China Times reported on May 17, 2006: a tertiary hospital located in Zhangzhou, Fujian province “performs at least 3000 transplants/year”. Source: Taiwanese businesses invested 1. 18 B dollars to build transplant center in Xiamen, The Epoch Times, May 3, 2006: http: //www. epochtimes. com/gb/6/5/3/n 1306378. htm 40
Media reports validate the large scale of transplants performed 3. Wuhan Tongji Hospital claims to have the largest group of living donor kidney transplant recipients. Each year, it performs thousands of kidney transplants. 41
Marketing: Organ Sales Promotion • On April 12, 2006, Jilin Heart Hospital offered “sales promotion” – only 50, 000 RMB for the first five heart transplant operations • On April 28, 2006, Hunan People’s Hospital offers 20 free liver and kidney transplants. 42
Hospitals Attract about 20 -Country Organ-needed Tourists Southern Weekly: Tens of Thousands Organ Tourists Visited China by 2006 Visitors from South Korea Japan India Malaysia Saudi Arabia Egypt United States Canada Taiwan 43
Smuggling Falun Gong Practitioners’Organs into Israel Yediot Achronot (the Israeli largest newspaper) reported: In August 2007, Israeli police arrested 4 human organ smugglers from China, who admitted organs were from political prisoners, death-row prisoners and Falun Gong practitioners. 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 44
Outline I. State Organized Crime: Order from the top II. Organ Transplants Exploded after 1999 III. Witnesses to Live Organ Harvesting IV. Organ Harvesting Rampant in China V. A Massive Live Organ Pool VI. Sources of organs & death row VII. Organ Transplants: Kill-on-Demand VIII. Falun Gong practitioners are victims of organ harvesting Appendix 45
V. A Massive Living Organ Pool 1. Short waiting time: one or two weeks 2. Emergency liver transplants with a kill-on-demand large supply 3. Multiple back-up organs ready for one transplant recipient 4. Hospitals do multiple transplant operations at the same time. A hospital even operated 24 liver/kidney transplants on one day. 5. Warm ischemia time is either zero or exceedingly short, indicating organ extraction from living candidates. 6. Falun Dafa practitioners are forced to have blood tests 46
Organ Transplants Waiting Time Year USA: 2 -3 years China: 1 -2 weeks Kidney Liver Source: An article about donating organs from the Metro newspaper online dated March, 29, 2006 47
Hospital Websites: Waiting Time 1 -2 Weeks The 2 nd Military Medical University Hospital: Average Liver Transplant waiting time is 1 week. 48
Hospital Websites: Waiting Time 1 -2 Weeks Oriental Organ Transplant Center, Tianjin First Center Hospital The average waiting time is 2 weeks. 49
Hospital Websites: Waiting Time 1 -2 Weeks … If any problem arises with the organ donor, a replacement organ can be found within a week. 50
Audio Recordings Testify to Constant Liver Supply 1. On June 26, 2015, (8613623711903), Dr. Chen Yongfeng from the Organ Transplant Department at Zhengzhou People’s Hospital told a WOIPFG investigator, “We can select a good and relatively young liver. We did liver transplant today. About 16 years old. Good liver. The other one is in the twenties. We have plenty of donors, so we can still select the ones that are young and good. It is hard to say if that will be the case down the road. ” 2. “The shortest wait time for a donor is approximately 2 -3 days, in general. The longest would be over 10 days. The cost is about 500, 000 yuan (approx. USD 78, 000). We have a lot of donors. ” On June 25, 2015, (8637163933151), a doctor-on -duty at the Department of Hepatobiliary Surgery of Zhengzhou People’s Hospital told an investigator: “The organs are directly sent to our operating rooms every day, one or two operations every day, guaranteed. ” 3. “Some patients would come at night, and we could do the operation over the same night. It's pretty common here. ” On March 19, 2015 (8637166862192), Dr. Li Gongquan, a liver transplant physician at the First Hospital Affiliated with Zhengzhou University, told a WOIPFG investigator over the phone: “[We could do it] within one week, if you like, we’ll go ahead and do the type 51 matching. ”
Forced blood tests -- Generating a living organ bank • Nearly every Falun Gong practitioner detained is forcibly subjected to blood tests, but not other inmates • Since 2014, Falun Gong practitioners are subjected to forcible blood tests in their homes. • These blood tests are not meant to ensure the wellbeing of Falun Gong practitioners, since a great number of them have been and continue to be slaughtered Ms. GAO Rongrong, formerly from the Lu Xun Academy of Fine Arts in Shenyang, was tortured to death under the watchful eye of the international community. 52
Outline I. State Organized Crime: Order from the top II. Organ Transplants Exploded after 1999 III. Witnesses to Live Organ Harvesting IV. Organ Harvesting Rampant in China V. A Massive Live Organ Pool VI. Sources of organs & death row VII. Organ Transplants: Kill-on-Demand VIII. Falun Gong practitioners are victims of organ harvesting Appendix 53
VI. Sources of Organs & Death Row 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Government: Death Row & Donation Data Government Liver Transplant Data Amnesty International’s Death Row Data China Red Cross Donation Data Millions of Falun Gong Detained and Forced Blood Tested 6. Hospitals Admitting Using Falun Gong Organs 54
VI. Sources of Organs and Death Row • The CCP Lies on Organ Sources • Death Row Prisoners Far Less Than Liver Transplants • Citizen Volunteer Donations Are Rare • Death Row + Donations Not Enough for a Hospital’s Transplants 55
CCP’s Lies on Organ Sources November 2005: Huang Jiefu, Vice Minister of Health said: “The majority, 95% of organs are from death row prisoners. ” November 2006, Huang said “Most organs are from death row prisoners” and “a small number comes from people who died of auto accidents. ” In March 2013, Huang Jiefu said: “For over the last decade, death row prisoners have decreased by 10% each year in our country, now death row prisoners are very limited. ” July 2013 and September 2014: 165 executed death row prisoners, according to official web China Judgment Online. Source: https: //zh. wikipedia. org/wiki/%E 4%B 8%AD%E 5%9 B%BD%E 5%99%A 8%E 5%AE%98%E 7%A 7%BB%E 6%A 4%8 D November 18, 2006, China Daily, In organ donations, charity begins with body http: //ndnews. oeeee. com/html/201303/07/29527. html http: //news. qq. com/newspedia/death. htm 56
China’s Death Row Prisoners Amnesty International Report: During 1995 -2005, five years before and after the persecution of Falun Gong, the annual average of death row prisoners in China was about 1, 616 《器官移植调查网》2006年 7月6日“Report into Allegations of Organ Harvesting of Falun Gong Practitioners in China”Author: Matas http: //organharvestinvestigation. net/report 060706 -eng. pdf zhuichaguoji. org 57
Liver/Kidney Transplants in China Far More than Death Row Prisoners Avg. annual 1, 616 death row prisoners March 2010, HUANG Jiefu gave the total volume of China’s organ transplant operations in Madrid 58
Liver Transplants outnumbered executed prisoners + donations Cases/year 2000 -05 Annual Avg. death row prisoners 1980 s-2009 total cases of citizen donation 2005 -2006 Liver Transplants 1, 616 120 8, 486 Source Amnesty International Huang Jiefu, Vice Minister of Health China Liver Transplant Registry 2016 Annual Report On Jan 8, 2015, HUANG Jiefu, Vice Minister of Health said on a Chinese healthcare website: “For a long time, China has not been able to establish a state-level organ donation system. From 1980 s to 2009, there had been only 120 cases of citizen donations. China is the country with the lowest number of organ donation in the world. ” Source: July 6, 2006, “Report into Allegations of Organ Harvesting of Falun Gong Practitioners in China” Author: Matas http: //organharvestinvestigation. net/report 060706 -eng. pdf 59
Even One Hospital’s Liver Transplants Outnumber All Death Row Prisoners Beijing University’s People’s Hospital alone did 4, 000 liver/kidney transplants in 2010. All death row prisoners annual average before 2010 in China (1, 616) were not enough for this one hospital alone. 3/15/2018 zhuichaguoji. org 60
In 2005 China Had the 1 st Organ Donation In 2005, Zhongshan University’s First Affiliated Hospital completed the organ transplant from China’s first organ donation. 61
China’s organ donation is among the lowest in the world On February 25, 2011, Yangzi Evening Newspaper reported: 0 Voluntary organ donation in Nanjing in 1 year： , In the past 20 years, Nanjing organ donation organizations received just 3 donations. Yangzi Evening Newspaper 62
Organ Donations Are Rare 1. Staff of Beijing Red Cross Society said：(on Dec 6, 2015, Phone number: 861063558766) “organ donation has not yet begun and the organization is in the planning process. ” (Note: Beijing has 20 large scale transplant centers with ample organ supply. From where? ) 2. Tianjin Red Cross workers said: (on Dec 11, 2015, Phone number: 862227311180) “Since the organ donation bank system was set up in 2003, more than 170 donations have been made, averaging only 13 per year. ” (Note: The First Central Hospital in Tianjin announced publicly alone it had performed 10, 000 transplant operations by 2014. ) 3. Staff of Shanghai Red Cross Organ Donation Office in Huangpu District said: (on Dec 17, 2015, 86 -63365880) “They only started this work during the first half of the previous year. They said a document was issued from a senior level regarding the process, and organ donations are very difficult. Up to today, there have been only five cases of organ donation in Shanghai. ” (Note: Shanghai has 20 transplant hospitals with high volume of transplants each year, including DCD transplants). 63
Outline I. State Organized Crime: Order from the top II. Organ Transplants Exploded after 1999 III. Witnesses to Live Organ Harvesting IV. Organ Harvesting Rampant in China V. A Massive Live Organ Pool VI. Sources of organs & death row VII. Organ Transplants: Kill-on-Demand VIII. Falun Gong practitioners are victims of organ harvesting Appendix 64
VII. Transplants: Kill-on-Demand • 5 Liver Transplants in 1 Hospital in 17 Hours • Two kidney transplants operations within 48 hours on the same patient • Three Living Candidates used for One Liver Transplant Surgery • 24 Liver & Kidney Transplants Performed in One Hospital on One Day • Emergency Liver Transplants: within 4 hours 65 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org
Kill-on-Demand: 5 Liver Transplants in 1 Hospital in 17 Hours Southeast Express reported on March 6, 2014: “Fuzhou Hospital General’s Talent Team Completed 5 Liver Transplant Operations within 17 Hours”. According to the article, the five patients had been admitted to the hospital and were waiting for livers, and “five matching livers had already been found but could only be extracted until five minutes after the donors’ hearts stopped beating. ” Apparently, the “donors” were still alive with functional livers while the livers were being matched to the recipients. The five patients had been admitted to the hospital, not waiting for suitable organ matching, but waiting for the death of the organ “donors”. Source: http: //news. fznews. com. cn/shehui/2014 -3 -6/201436 GBn. LAp. FSxx 103423_2. shtml 66
Two kidney transplants operations within 48 hours on the same patient Getting a new kidney is as easy as buying a pig’s kidney in mainland China, according to a Huaxia Times article published on May 17, 2006 According to a Huaxia report, Han Xiuwu, the chief physician at Beijing Haidian Hospital’s organ transplant center, completed two kidney transplant operations on the same patient within 48 hours in December 2004. The first operation failed due to hyper-acute rejection, so Han conducted the second kidney transplant the following day. According to the report, this case was widely discussed by people, “In other countries, patients usually have to wait a few years for a precious kidney. But Haidian Hospital could obtain kidneys as easy as if they were pigs’ kidneys. The first donor kidney was acquired within nine days. As for the second kidney, they could just go and get it. Isn’t it strange? ” Source: (2006) http: //www. chinatimes. cc/news/srbd. asp? id=53882 http: //www. med 66. com/html/ziliao/07/0/17373 c 334 f 8 faa 51 a 00155 d 7 a 014 ccf 0. htm 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 67
Huang Jiefu Uses: Three Living Candidates for One Liver Transplant Surgery On the afternoon of Sept. 28, 2005, Vice Minister of Health Huang Jiefu demonstrated a autologous liver transplant surgery at the First Affiliated Hospital of Xinjiang Medical University. i. Feng Weekly: The Shady Deal of Human Organ Trade in China, Nov. 2013 He had 3 backup living candidates for this operation, from cities far away across the country. People’s Daily Online: The Meritorious Deeds of Tan Jianming WOIPFG Archive: http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org/cn/images/nationalcriminalreports/172. png 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 68
24 Liver & Kidney Transplants Performed in One Hospital in One Day In 2014, WOIPFG released an online investigative report. 42 hospitals were found to have published articles indicating they performed multiple transplant operations simultaneously. Tianjin First Central Hospital Source: transplantation. org. cn: an Overview of Tianjin First Central Hospital 69
Emergency Transplants: 26. 6% 4 -Hour Waiting Time An emergency liver transplant is an urgent operation performed on patients with acute, serious liver problems and can only live less than 72 hours. According to China Liver Transplant Registry 2016 Annual Report, 8, 486 liver transplants in were performed in 29 transplant centers from April 6, 2005 to December 31, 2006. Of these, 4, 331 cases had specified whether or not the case was an emergency transplant, indicating a total of 1, 150 emergency transplants ---- 26. 6%! Shanghai Changzheng Hospital, an affiliated hospital of the Second Military Medical University, performed 120 emergency liver transplant operations during the three years from 2003 to 2006. The shortest wait time for receiving a transplant after the patient was admitted was four hours. 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 70
One Patient Used 8 kidneys in 2 months Bloody Harvest: In 2003, Dr. Tan Jianming of Nanjing Military Region finally succeeded transplanting a kidney on a patient in Shanghai, after using 8 kidneys in 2 months. When the 8 th kidney proved matching, the transplant was finally succeeded. 摘自《血淋淋的器官摘取》 3/15/2018 http: //www. epochtimes. com/gb/7/3/26/n 1657563. htm zhuichaguoji. org 71
Outline I. State Organized Crime: Order from the top II. Organ Transplants Exploded after 1999 III. Witnesses to Live Organ Harvesting IV. Organ Harvesting Rampant in China V. A Massive Live Organ Pool VI. Sources of organs & death row VII. Organ Transplants: Kill-on-Demand VIII. Falun Gong practitioners are victims of organ harvesting IX. Conclusions Appendix 72
Organ Transplants in a Tianjin Hospital Surpass that of Germany On July 24, 2006, at the First World Organ Transplant Academic Conference, a surgeon from Tianjin told Dr. Torsten Trey his hospital conducted about 2, 000 cases of liver transplants in one year. “This number is more than the total number of operations in Germany, we have to ask where their liver donors come from ? ” said Dr. Torsten Trey. The Epoch Times , expert: Neglecting Organ Harvesting Shames the Transplant Industry: http: //www. epochtimes. com/gb/6/7/25/n 1397743. htm 73
Falun Gong Practitioners: Victims of Organ Harvesting • Falun Gong practitioners in many concentration camps • Falun Gong practitioners are codified & organ harvested • Lists of Doctors/Hospitals admitted using their organs • Armed guard witnessed the organ harvesting operation • Police Zhu Jiabin boasted his harvesting & selling their organs 74
Falun Gong Practitioners in Concentration Camps On October 1, 2000, the Agence France Presse (AFP) reported that the CCP had built concentration camps in Northeast and Northwest China. These camps were each able to hold 50, 000 detainees. In 2006, a senior medical officer reported that there’re 36 camps for detaining Falun Gong in the country, and the detained become victims of organ harvesting. The largest camp detained over 120, 000 people. Many of the camps are military facilities. The Epoch Times, Senior Medical Officer from Shen Yang military zone exposes the Sujiatun Concentration Camp: http: //www. epochtimes. com/b 5/6/3/31/n 1271996. htm Evidence of CCP’s Organ Harvesting crimes collected by WOIPFG: http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org/node/46728#_Toc 366574827 75
Codifying and Organ Harvesting Falun Gong Practitioners 1. In 2006, according to a senior medical officer: “Any individual identified as a candidate for organ harvesting would be taken away from prison, labor camp, detention center or camp. From then on, they would no longer have a name; instead, they would be given a code number and a corresponding set of fabricated data of a volunteer donor that does not exist. ” 2. Chen Qiang of PLA No. 307 Hospital: “Could find the code number [of the Falun Gong organ candidate] if he couldn’t find the real name, you know……and there’s also finger prints” 76
Doctors & Hospitals Admitted Organs are from Falun Gong Practitioners 77
Doctors & Hospitals Admitted Organs are from Falun Gong Practitioners 78
Testimony of Onsite Armed Guard during the Operation of Live Organ Harvesting Date: April 9, 2002, Time: The operation began at 5: 00 pm, ended at 8: 00 pm Location: in a surgery room on the 15 th floor of the General Hospital of Shenyang Military Region The guard saw: A female Falun Gong practitioner in her 30 s (she was a teacher)，covered with wounds and scars over her entire body, the result of a week of torture, rape, and force-feeding. Two military doctors, without applying any anesthesia, extracted her heart, kidneys and other organs while she remained fully conscious, cold-bloodedly killing her in the process. (Please see full recording and text in appendix. ) 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 79
Police Zhu Jiabin Admitted to Harvesting and “Selling” Organs From January to June 2016, WOIPFG’s recording of the killer: Zhu Jiabin, the head of the general department of the CCP’s“ 610 Office” in Mudanjiang City, Heilongjiang Province, admitted in a high-profile way to live organ harvesting Falun Gong practitioner Gao Yixi. Sounding to be unscrupulous and emboldened in the knowledge of being backed up, he said that he had “sold” Gao’s organs. Investigator: You carved out his organs, and (you think) you can get away with it? Zhu Jiabin… Zhu Jiabin: Sold them! Investigator: Ah? Zhu Jiabin: All sold, they were all sold. (Please see full recording and text in appendix. ) 2016 Latest WOIPFG report: http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org/node/67047 80
Outline I. State Organized Crime: Order from the top II. Organ Transplants Exploded after 1999 III. Witnesses to Live Organ Harvesting IV. Organ Harvesting Rampant in China V. A Massive Live Organ Pool VI. Sources of organs & death row VII. Organ Transplants: Kill-on-Demand VIII. Falun Gong practitioners are victims of organ harvesting IX. Conclusions Appendix 81
IX. Conclusions • Live organ harvesting on Falun Gong practitioners is a state organized crime ordered by Jiang Zemin. • Organ harvesting escalated in 1999, rampant nationwide. • Government officials, police, military, legal system, hospitals, doctors collaborate in the evil crime. • Organ harvesting has become a huge profitable business: website ads, sales promotion, marketing and agents are used to attract foreign patients, or smuggle organs to foreign countries. • With a large pool of Falun Gong practitioners imprisoned, organs are made available by killing on demand. • Surgeons and police even boast to have harvested and sold organs from live people. • The CCP has been using army, police, legal systems, governments and hospitals to commit genocide against good-hearted people. • All people and countries should act to stop the crime against humanity. 82
Outline I. State Organized Crime: Order from the top II. Organ Transplants Exploded after 1999 III. Witnesses to Live Organ Harvesting IV. Organ Harvesting Rampant in China V. A Massive Live Organ Pool VI. Sources of organs & death row VII. Organ Transplants: Kill-on-Demand VIII. Falun Gong practitioners are victims of organ harvesting IX. Conclusions Appendix 83
Appendix: Appendix I: A Full Testimony by the Onsite Armed Guard during the Operation of Live Organ Harvesting Appendix II: Police Zhu Jiabin Admitted to Harvesting and “Selling” Organs Appendix III: Falun Gong and the Persecution Appendix IV: WOIPF and Its Report on Organ Harvesting 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 84
Appendix I: A Full Testimony by the Onsite Armed Guard during the Operation of Live Organ Harvesting On April 9, 2002, an armed guard was an eyewitness to a surgery, in an operating room on the 15 th floor of the General Hospital of Shenyang Military Command, PLA. The guard observed two military doctors extract organ(s) from a female Falun Gong practitioner without administering any anesthesia. The Military Identification No. of one of the doctors is 0106069. The victim was a middle school teacher in her thirties. Before the doctors killed her, she had been subjected to a month of severe torture, molestation and rape. 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 85
Appendix I: Recording and Text A Full Testimony by Onsite Armed Guard during the Operation of Live Organ Harvesting Eyewitness: If I am still alive in the future, can you help me reprint the information provided here elsewhere? Investigator: Okay, I promise you. Eyewitness: If I’m dead, you can find others or ask about what I’ve … or you can write an article about what I have done. I am not trying to make a name for myself, I want more people like me to speak out, to have the courage to tell the truth. …… Investigator: You haven’t told me the date. Eyewitness: April 9, 2002. Investigator: April 9? Eyewitness: Yes, the extraction began at 5 PM on April 9, and lasted 3 hours. It had continued for one month already. 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 86
活摘現場持槍警衛證詞 2002年 4月9日，在瀋陽軍區總醫院 15樓的一間手術室內，證人 持槍警衛，親眼看到兩個軍醫（其中一名軍官證號碼 0106069） 將一名30多歲的修鍊法輪功的中學女教師，在沒打麻藥的情況下， 活生生地摘取了她的心、肝、腎器官。在此之前，女教師遭受了 一個月的嚴刑拷打、侮辱和強暴。 证人：以后如果我还活着的话，你就帮我转载这些东西。 调查员：好，我答应你。 证人：如果我要是死了，你就找别人，或者打听我这个……, 或者是把我这 个事迹做成一个文章，我倒是不是为了让他们知道我，为了让更多的我出 来，敢于说真话。 …… 调查员：哪个时间你还没有告诉我？ 证人： 2002年 4月9日。 调查员： 4月9日？ 证人：对 4月9日下午5点开始解剖，时间进行了3个小时。之前已经连续一 87 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 87 个月了。
Testimony by Eyewitness to Organ Harvesting Investigator: What do you mean “continued for one month already? ” Eyewitness: The extortion of a confession through torture had continued for one month already. Investigator: Did you extort confessions by torture from them only once, or many times? Eyewitness: Many times. At the time, Wang Lijun is the sitting chief of the Chongqing Public Security Bureau, he gave the strict order that all of them must be exterminated. Investigator: Okay, so, you witnessed firsthand, or, how many Falun Gong practitioners being persecuted would you say you witnessed firsthand? Eyewitness: I witnessed, I wasn’t exposed to too many, about 20 to 30 people. Investigator: 20 to 30 people. Die, anyone die? Was anyone tortured to death? Eyewitness: Of course, of course. During one week at the detention center three people were hanged. While they were in the detention house, people from the Public Security Bureau told people in the detention house, “Let the jailer and prisoners beat them brutally, ” and three died in one week. This means, there were many others, many more. For example, later [they would say]… aiya (a common emphatic expression in Chinese, which is like a sigh), he committed suicide, they would say, it was an accident, accident. 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 88
Testimony by Eyewitness to Organ Harvesting Eyewitness: It didn’t take me long, as a police officer, when you saw that no matter how you beat them, for the sake of their faith, their belief, even if it’s for the sake of a “cult, ” even if they had elderly parents and young children at home, they refused [ to yield ]. It is very easy because we arrest murderers, and they confess as soon as we begin interrogating. But when the military doctors cut her stomach open, extracted her kidneys without using any anesthesia, she, didn’t even make a sound, she just sweated a lot, and even by then, she said “Falun Dafa is good. ” Investigator: You saw that firsthand? Eyewitness: Corneas, kidneys, hearts… …, they even extracted brains, I don’t know for what purpose. Investigator: How many times did you witness organ harvesting? Eyewitness: As an eyewitness, only once. 89 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org
![Testimony by Eyewitness to Organ Harvesting Eyewitness: The scalpel, the scalpel [was held] by](https://present5.com/presentation/a53093fb5d02ff8a00b6b52c60ca1a19/image-90.jpg "Testimony by Eyewitness to Organ Harvesting Eyewitness: The scalpel, the scalpel [was held] by")
Testimony by Eyewitness to Organ Harvesting Eyewitness: The scalpel, the scalpel [was held] by the chest, when it cut into the victim, the blood gushed out instead of… Investigator: Was the victim a man or a woman? Eyewitness: A woman. Investigator: Was she young? Eyewitness: A little over 30 years old. Investigator: Was she still shouting “Falun Dafa is good”? Eyewitness: She was still shouting, still shouting that. Investigator: Tell me how she said it. Eyewitness: We had interrogated and brutally tortured her for a week already. Her body was covered in countless wounds and scars. We had shocked her with stun guns, stunned her. She had been out of her wits…out of her wits. She had lost her mind, basically. She had also been refusing food, so we had to force feed her milk into her stomach. Whenever she refused, we had to force feed her. You know when you pinch a person’s nose, the person has to instinctively open up the mouth and swallow. So that’s how we had kept her alive. She had lost 15 Jin (a unit of weight equal to half a kilogram) in 7 days. 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 90
Testimony by Eyewitness to Organ Harvesting Eyewitness: And then I wasn’t sure who–maybe some office at the Public Security Bureau of Liaoning province, anyway, it was a very secretive office–they sent two people. One was a military doctor from the General Hospital of Shenyang Military Command, PLA. One was a graduate of the Second Military Medical University. Basically, one was more elderly, the other one was young. Certainly, certainly, basically, she was sent to an operating room at a psychiatric hospital, and a set of procedures were performed on her. They did not administer any anesthesia to her. They held the scalpel by her chest. Their hands did not tremble at all. If it were me, I would have trembled for sure. I had served in the armed police force, I carried a gun and I participated in military exercises with real ammo, and I’ve seen lots of dead bodies, but when I saw those military doctors, I had to give it to them. Their hands did not tremble at all. They just pulled up their masks and [the gurney] was pulled close. We each held a gun and stood to the side, guarding. They had already cut into her, she screamed, the woman screamed, and shouted “Falun Dafa is good”. 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 91
![Testimony by Eyewitness to Organ Harvesting Eyewitness: [She] screamed, and said “Falun Dafa is](https://present5.com/presentation/a53093fb5d02ff8a00b6b52c60ca1a19/image-92.jpg "Testimony by Eyewitness to Organ Harvesting Eyewitness: [She] screamed, and said “Falun Dafa is")
Testimony by Eyewitness to Organ Harvesting Eyewitness: [She] screamed, and said “Falun Dafa is good”. [She] said, you can kill me. Basically, she meant you can kill me, but can you kill hundreds of millions of us, people who are being persecuted for believing in a true faith. At that moment, the doctors, the military doctors, hesitated. They shot me a glance, and then shot our senior official a glance, and the official nodded. He continued with the blood vessel…first was the extraction of the heart, and then the extraction of the kidneys. When the scissor cut into a blood vessel in the heart, she began convulsing, it was extremely terrifying. I can imitate her screams, but I am not good at it. Her screams were like something was tearing up, and then, ahhh…. her mouth was gaping, her eyes popping, mouth gaping. Oh dear…I can’t go on talking about this. Investigator: I understand. Do you know her name? Eyewitness: Her name is…I can’t disclose that, I can’t tell you that, because there were only a few of us in that operating room. … Eyewitness: How about this, I will give her a code name, how about “Xue Mei Gui” (“Snow Rose”). Her name means a kind of flower, so we will call her “Xue Mei Gui”. 92 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org
Testimony by Eyewitness to Organ Harvesting Investigator: We will call her “Xue Mei”, “Mei” as in “Mei Gui” (“Rose”). Eyewitness: You could also use “Mei” as in “Mei Hua” (“Plum Blossom”). Investigator: Okay, Xue Mei it is then. Eyewitness: At the time, she was a teacher, a teacher at a middle school. I think her son should be 12 years old this year. Her husband is not someone with abilities or means, I think he’s a factory worker. Prior to her death, she had been through unspeakable molestation. A lot of the policemen are very sexually perverted. What they did to her, they used pliers, vaginal speculum. I don’t know where they got that equipment. These things I witnessed firsthand. I only regret that I did not take any photographs of what they did. The policemen sexually violated her. She was kind of good looking, kind of pretty. They raped her… they did so many such things [to her]. Investigator: You witnessed this at the Public Security Bureau you were working at… Eyewitness: Back then I wasn’t working at the Public Security Bureau. We were at a training center. Basically, it was in the back of a hotel. We rented 10 rooms in a building, they did these things in that building. 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 93
Testimony by Eyewitness to Organ Harvesting Investigator: A black jail. Eyewitness: That’s pretty much what it was. Investigator: All Falun Gong practitioners were sent there. Eyewitness: Yes. Investigator: Before they were sentenced, they were held captive there. Eyewitness: We often change locations at the last minute. Eyewitness: I never hurt her myself, it’s just that I wasn’t able to save her…I was unable to save her. All the other policemen there were more senior to me in rank, I couldn’t save her. Investigator: And you were still very young. Eyewitness: I was only 22 years old. Investigator: And you thought it was the Party who asked you to do this, you thought you were just fulfilling your duty. Eyewitness: Yes. To be frank, I never liked the Party, not even from day one. I was just trying to earn my salary, and be promoted to a senior official in the future. I guess I was selfish. Investigator: Today you shared the most precious part of your soul. Eyewitness: I've only told you about these things. I rarely tell anybody about these things. 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org 94
Testimony by Eyewitness to Organ Harvesting Investigator: It’s of course very dark, but you are a person with conscience, which is why you agreed to… Eyewitness: I must say something to you practitioners, a few words of advice. Don’t plead with communist bastards, basically, don’t expect anything from them. You can’t afford to be that kind, you can’t afford to be so benevolent. The way I see it, you are too kind for your own good, you practitioners are too kind for your own good. Investigator: We understand these things. The only way to disintegrate the most evil beings is through the greatest compassion and the greatest kindness. Eyewitness: How can you act like that with the devil? Devils will never…. because they are evil demons. Eyewitness: Before, I never believed in those things. I never believed. But after what I’ve seen, I’m completely taken aback by their courage. No matter how much endurance a human being can have, you have to understand that when a sharp scalpel slowly cuts your chest open, you see the heart beating inside, the blood gushing out. 95 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org
Testimony by Eyewitness to Organ Harvesting Eyewitness: There were other things that were even more sinister, basically…I feel that I owe her, whenever I think back to that moment, I feel I owe her. I couldn’t save her. Investigator: Because gods are compassionate, and in your heart, you wanted to save her, so in fact, at the time, she should have felt… Eyewitness: At the time, my gun was loaded. I even had this thought, I had 10 bullets in my gun, and there were 5 people in that room. I wanted to shoot all of them. 96 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org
Appendix II: Recording and Text Police Zhu Jiabin Admitted to Harvesting and “Selling” Organs From January to June 2016, WOIPFG’s recording of the killer: Zhu Jiabin, the head of the general department of the CCP’s“ 610 Office” in Mudanjiang City, Heilongjiang Province, admitted in a high-profile way to live organ harvesting Falun Gong practitioner Gao Yixi. Sounding to be unscrupulous and emboldened in the knowledge of being backed up, he said that he had “sold” Gao’s organs. Investigator: You carved out his organs, and (you think) you can get away with it? Zhu Jiabin… Zhu Jiabin: Sold them! Investigator: Ah? Zhu Jiabin: All sold, they were all sold. 2016 Latest WOIPFG report: http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org/node/67047 97
Police Zhu Jiabin Admitted to Harvesting and “Selling” Organs Investigator: It is ok for you to have sold them, how can you say this so easily? What if Gao Yixi were your brother, would you still talk like this? Zhu Jiabin: That was just the human stuff. After slaughtering and opening up the belly, you just carve out (the organs), and sell them. Investigator: Let me tell you, Zhu Jiabin, you are the head of the 610 (office). This is written very clearly on international websites. You know that the 610 at the beginning was Jiang Zemin persecuted Falun Gong…an illegal organization set up to persecute Falun Gong. Your department is illegal and above the law, do you know? Zhu Jiabin: I do not know. Investigator: You participated in live organ harvesting of Gao Yixi, and you even said such things. Don’t you have a heart (i. e. conscience)? Where is your conscience? Zhu Jiabin: Yes, I do have. Here it is! I see it is thumping, thumping! Investigator: You’ve sold someone else’s organs, and you even say something like this? ! Are you still human? ! Zhu Jiabin: You even. . . 98
Police Zhu Jiabin Admitted to Harvesting and “Selling” Organs Investigator: Humans should have human nature. You are such people without human nature, and you even say such things. If this happened to your family and friends, would you think like this? Zhu Jiabin: If you appeared in front of me, I would also live organ harvest you, do you believe it or not? Investigator: You should know that good and evil will be repaid, which is a heavenly principle. Do you know this principle? Zhu Jiabin: I don’t know. I only know to sell (organs) for money after (organ) harvesting. This is my principle. Investigator: Let me tell you. Can you bear to spend this money? Ah? If people from your family were live organ harvested and (had their organs) sold by others, could you (bear it)? You! Zhu Jiabin: Don’t you know my nickname? Investigator: Murderers must pay with their lives, do you know? Zhu Jiabin: I have just told you. If you had guts to stand in front of me right now, I would live organ harvest you all the same. My nickname is “the butcher”. 99
Police Zhu Jiabin Admitted to Harvesting and “Selling” Organs Investigator: Let me tell you~ Zhu Jiabin: Next time, next time, when you phone me, don’t call me by my name. I’ve changed my name, and I am now called “the butcher”. Investigator: Let me tell you. You persecute Falun Gong, and you’ve live organ harvested Falun Gong practitioner Gao Yixi. We will track down and hold you responsible for your crimes, do you know? Zhu Jiabin: Just track me down! I am number one in the world. What do I fear? I am called the butcher, specializing in live organ harvesting! Investigator: You are so outrageous. You think nobody can punish you, right? Zhu Jiabin: Who would dare to punish me? Investigator: The law, are you the law, right? You 610 (Office) is above the law and an illegal organization. Zhu Jiabin: That I don’t know. It was said by you that I am lawless. I feel very good. It’s nothing, just like slaughtering pigs. You come over to shave the hair first, and then split open the belly. I would carve out whatever I need. After scoping (the organs) out, I would sell them. How wonderful? How fast the money would come… 100
Appendix III: Falun Gong and the Persecution • • What is Falun Gong/Falun Dafa? Falun Gong practice prior to 1999 Health Benefits Jiang Zemin initiated the persecution Nationwide propaganda to smother Arrest, Torture and Imprison Falun Gong Forced Live Organ Harvesting 101
What is Falun Gong? (or Falun Dafa) • A peaceful mind-body meditation practice including gentle exercises and based on the spiritual principles of - Truthfulness - Compassion - Forbearance An ancient practice that was re-introduced to the public in China in 1992 102
Falun Gong Widely Practiced in China Prior to 1999 An official of China Sports Commission: “Falun Gong and other types of qi gong can save each person 1, 000 yuan in annual medical fees. If 100 million people are practicing it, that’s 100 billion yuan saved per year in medical fees. Premier Zhu Rongji is very happy about that. The country could use the money right now. ” 103 -- U. S. News and World Report, February 1999
Falun Dafa Practitioners at Various Cities in China • Top left: Harbin, Heilongjiang Province • Top right: Weifang, Shandong Province, 1998 • Bottom left: Beijing, 1996 104
Washington DC Paris Bali, Indonesia Russia Australia Japan Taiwan 105
An Beijing Health Survey in 1998 l l Total Surveyed: 12, 731 practitioners Gender: 72% female 28% male Age (year): 67. 5% > 50 30. 8% 20 -50 1. 7% < 20 Practice Length: 25% < 1 year 53% 1 -3 year 22% > 3 year Before practice 93. 4% with one or more diseases l After practice Recovery from illness 58. 5% full recovery 40. 6% partial recovery 0. 9% no change l Stress reduction 96. 5% 106 http: //www. minghui. org/mh/articles/1999/7/9/%E 7%9 C%9 F%E http: //pureinsight. org/node/841
The Persecution of Falun Gong • Initiated by: Jiang Zemin, the former head of CCP • Conducted by: 6 -10 Office • Policy: - Ruin the reputation, block the finance, destroy the body. - Beating to death is regarded as suicide, - Do not check where they’re from, cremate directly. • Means: State-run media defaming, job dismissing, brainwashing, labor-camps, jails, physical and mental torture, psychiatrical abuse, live organ harvesting, etc. 107
Unprecedented Propaganda Attempted to Smother Falun Gong Ø President Jiang Zemin initiated & orchestrated the campaign against Falun Gong. Ø State-run media, TV, newspapers, and radio flooded fabricated stories to defame Falun Gong. Ø Internet access to Falun Gong websites was blocked to Chinese people. Ø The Great Firewall was built to censor all references to Falun Gong. 108
Mass Arrest & Arbitrary Detention 10. 1. 2000 October 1 st, 2000, China’s National Day, one plainclothes police steps on a practitioner’s head as the other puts a knife at his neck. (AP photo) 11. 16. 1999 November 16 th, 1999, plainclothes policemen became the major force arresting peaceful Falun Gong practitioners. (AP photo)) 109
Plainclothes and police beating and arresting practitioners in Tiananmen Square 110
Mr. Ma Xuejun, an officer at Jiamusi Railway Bureau, arrested 7 times because he practices Falun Gong. He was sentenced 12 years and tortured almost to death. 111
Ms. Gao Rongrong Police shocked Gao Rongrong on her face with a 30, 000 volt electric baton for 7 hours. Gao was tortured to death on June 16, 2005. 112
APPENDIX IV: WOIPFG-- An Overview WOIPFG (World Organization to Investigate the Persecution of Falun Gong) was established on January 20, 2003. WOIPFG is headquartered in New York, with branches in Europe, Australia, Asia and Canada. WOIPFG’s mission: To investigate the criminal conduct of all institutions, organizations, and individuals involved in the persecution; To exercise fundamental principles of humanity; and To restore and uphold justice in society. 113 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org
WOIPFG’s Efforts and Report • • Ten years of investigation since April 2006 Published a 210 k word report on live organ harvesting Made over 10, 000 investigative phone calls Interviewed all walks of life from court, government, hospitals, schools, army, police, etc. • Obtained evidence directly from 5 members of Polibureau’s Standing Committee • Obtained website records & voice records from 891 hospitals • Talked with 9, 519 doctors involving organ transplants Note: Data for this presentation all come from WOGIPF. 114 3/15/2018 http: //www. zhuichaguoji. org
Скачать презентацию Ten Years of Investigation Irrefutable Evidence Organ Harvesting
a53093fb5d02ff8a00b6b52c60ca1a19.ppt