Contributions from process research Anthony Pym © Intercultural Studies Group Universitat Rovira i Virgili Plaça Imperial Tàrraco 1 43005 Tarragona Fax: (++ 34) 977 55 95 97
What we teach comes from… n n n Mindless reproduction Suppositions about the market Evaluations of output (grading schemes) Surveys of market needs? Process research comparing novices and professionals? © Intercultural Studies Group
Process studies use n n n Think-Aloud Protocols (TAPs) Translog Screen recording Eye-tracking Post-performance interviews © Intercultural Studies Group
TAPs © Intercultural Studies Group
Translog © Intercultural Studies Group
Eyetracking © Intercultural Studies Group
More experienced translators… 1) use more paraphrase and less literalism as coping strategies (Kussmaul 1995, Lörscher 1991, Jensen 1999) © Intercultural Studies Group
More experienced translators… 2) process larger translation units (Toury 1986, Lörscher 1991, Tirkkonen-Condit 1992) © Intercultural Studies Group
More experienced translators… 3) spend longer reviewing their work at the postdrafting phase but make fewer changes when reviewing (Jensen and Jakobsen 2000, Jakobsen 2002, Englund Dimitrova 2005) © Intercultural Studies Group
More experienced translators… 4) read texts faster and spend proportionally more time looking at the target text than at the source text (Jakobsen and Jensen 2008) © Intercultural Studies Group
More experienced translators… 5) use top-down processing and refer more to the translation purpose (Fraser 1996; Jonasson 1998; Künzli 2001, 2004, Séguinot 1989, Tirkkonen-Condit 1992) © Intercultural Studies Group
More experienced translators… 6) rely on encyclopaedic knowledge as opposed to ST construal (Tirkkonen-Condit 1989) © Intercultural Studies Group
More experienced translators… 7) express more principles and personal theories (Tirkkonen-Condit 1989, 1997, Jääskeläinen 1999) © Intercultural Studies Group
More experienced translators… 8) incorporate the client into the risk-management processes (Künzli 2004) © Intercultural Studies Group
More experienced translators… 9) automatize some complex tasks but also shift between automatized routine tasks and conscious problem-solving (Krings 1988, Jääskeläinen and Tirkkonen-Condit 1991, Englund Dimitrova 2005) © Intercultural Studies Group
More experienced translators… 10) display more realism, confidence and critical attitudes in their decision-making (Künzli 2004) © Intercultural Studies Group
Aspects not normally covered n n n speed the capacity to distribute effort in terms of risk the restrained use of external resources (both written and human) the key role of revision/reviewing (new technologies). © Intercultural Studies Group
Experiments as good pedagogy n n House (1986, 2000); “translation in and as interaction” Self-awareness Awareness of other translation cultures Awareness of diversity within translation cultures. © Intercultural Studies Group
Activity n n n Open BB Flashback Start recording Translate the text GALEO 4710 as quickly as possible. Stop the recording Play back the recording at x 4 speed answer the following questions. © Intercultural Studies Group
Questions on activity n n n n Did you read the whole text before translating? How many times did you search for terms or images? Could you reduce the number of times? Did you change your translation as you went, or did you revise at the end? How long did you revise for? Did you look more at the ST or the TT? Did you ask who your client or reader was? Or what the purpose was? How did you render the colon? © Intercultural Studies Group
Experiment 1: Norms n When translating publicity from English, do you keep the name of the product in English script, transcribe it, and/or explain it? © Intercultural Studies Group
What 143 students did © Intercultural Studies Group
Experiment 2: Skopos n Do you explain the reference “Eton” in accordance with the instructions given for the translation? n History book vs. Coffee-table book n Moral philosophy vs. Biography. © Intercultural Studies Group
Experiment 2: Skopos 1 2 3 4 5 6 = = = Eton / THAT school or similar Eton SCHOOL / Eton PRESTIGIOUS school Eton / Eton a prestigious school LIKE Eton a prestigious school / Ivy league school © Intercultural Studies Group
Experiment 2: results © Intercultural Studies Group
Experiment 3: MT or not? © Intercultural Studies Group
Experiment 4: Speed n n n Students screen-record two comparable translations. The second is 33% faster than the first. Students analyze time-on-task for reading/comprehension, documentation, drafting, reviewing. © Intercultural Studies Group
Experiment 4: Speed © Intercultural Studies Group
Experiment 4: Speed reports n n K 1: I spent a lot less time researching, When you have a time limit, your efficiency goes up and you just focus on the text. C 2: This time I took less time on reading and translating [he increased the percentage of reviewing] C 4: More time spent on documentation and translation; significantly less time on revision. C 5: I just caught the rough meaning of the sentences and got to the translation right away in order to finish the translation before the time limit. © Intercultural Studies Group
Experiment 4: Recommendations n n n C 5: I think the secret to translate faster is not to hesitate for too long before starting to translate and make revisions afterward so you won’t waste too much time sticking in the phrases you have problems coming up with the best translation. C 7: What I recommend is try to cut from the documentation part and the revision part, but not the reading and comprehending part if the translator wants to make as little mistake as possible. F 1: For a person trying to translate quickly, I would say to avoid documentation if at all possible, and do some revising at the end to revisit those sections that were difficult or of which there were some uncertainties. © Intercultural Studies Group
![Experiment 4: Recommendations n F 3 […] There is, though, the factor of the](https://present5.com/presentation/7b6e18e016ab7b3feb9124971c76e66e/image-31.jpg "Experiment 4: Recommendations n F 3 […] There is, though, the factor of the")
Experiment 4: Recommendations n F 3 […] There is, though, the factor of the reading and comprehension, which during the first week seemed like discrete units but under time pressure blended much more into the translation phase. © Intercultural Studies Group
Summary n n Students experiment to discover things about themselves. They draw their own conclusions. The help improve professional research. They help discover the competencies they need to learn. © Intercultural Studies Group
Скачать презентацию Contributions from process research Anthony Pym Intercultural
7b6e18e016ab7b3feb9124971c76e66e.ppt