Скачать презентацию Feedback from The SWITCH Video Group The Скачать презентацию Feedback from The SWITCH Video Group The

a38f7c28e26e1f66b50b4d90000586e5.ppt

  • Количество слайдов: 14

Feedback from The SWITCH Video Group Feedback from The SWITCH Video Group

The Resource People In the beginning they were our friends… The Resource People In the beginning they were our friends…

Process Documentation Plan Group A Issue: Community Buy-in to plans for Wasiak Reservoir SWITCH Process Documentation Plan Group A Issue: Community Buy-in to plans for Wasiak Reservoir SWITCH TOC: Building a reservoir will save the area from occasional flooding & provide lovely recreational space leading to better quality of life. Specific Challenges: First to get them to look at river as ‘river’; to find feasible alternatives to sewage dumping

Process Documentation Plan Group A Purpose of the Plan: Internal learning- learning from a Process Documentation Plan Group A Purpose of the Plan: Internal learning- learning from a challenge to theory of change How will the Captured Info be Analysed: 2 perspectives on the problems in the area; something of the life of the community members; c’ty ambitions for the area; ‘experts’ response

Process Documentation Plan Group A Which are the processes this will capture: The broader Process Documentation Plan Group A Which are the processes this will capture: The broader process is rehabilitation of Sokotowka & this is about documenting c’ty impression of some of these plans. With Whom: Primarily c’ty members; experts (conceptualisation & implementation) Where: the planned site & community by the site

Process Documentation Plan Group A How will info. Be Disseminated: At presentation to LA Process Documentation Plan Group A How will info. Be Disseminated: At presentation to LA exhibition How will the purpose of the plan(? ) be monitored: LA facilitators may document any adjustments in plans/approach as a result of this video. Could also do another video of c’ty portraits after 5 years.

Process Documentation Plan Group B Issue/TOC: Storm water management through construction of reservoirs Specific Process Documentation Plan Group B Issue/TOC: Storm water management through construction of reservoirs Specific Challenges: Solve problem of pollution (heavy metals), Social acceptance (what happened in the past? Changes operated in people’s mind?

Process Documentation Plan Group B What are the processes this plan will capture: Different Process Documentation Plan Group B What are the processes this plan will capture: Different ideas concerning the benefits of reservoirs and the impact in the population (social and pollution impact) With whom, where, when can these issues be captured: Where: concrete reservoir, park, dry part (if time allow us) With Whom: Mrs. Lukasz for photo remediation, Mrs. Teresa Wozniak , The people responsible, Locals: using the concrete reservoir

Process Documentation Plan Group B Purpose of the plan: External ( to show successful Process Documentation Plan Group B Purpose of the plan: External ( to show successful the process has been) Format: Documentary, interview Purpose is for external: Not necessary to make strategy know

Reflections on Experience How important was the planning? n What were your expectations – Reflections on Experience How important was the planning? n What were your expectations – and how far were they met? n How did the dynamics of working in a team affect the production process? And did we think there any advantages of documenting processes as a team? n What would you say are the advantages & disadvantages of video for process doc? n

How Important Was The Planning? n Very, very- clarifying what IS process n Decisions How Important Was The Planning? n Very, very- clarifying what IS process n Decisions that you make in the field inform what ends up screen, decisions informed by planning…but also makes mockery of planning n What distinguishes us from other type of filmmakers (like anthropological documents)

What were your expectations? n Finished product n Realised how we underestimated the time What were your expectations? n Finished product n Realised how we underestimated the time & complexity n Finally – aware of the time & effort – now very pleased with what we achieved n Planned sequence of shooting (ha!)

How did the dynamics of team affect production process? Recognise the limitations of democracy How did the dynamics of team affect production process? Recognise the limitations of democracy n Hardship brings social capital (bonding) n Flexibility of roles more than we expected n More consensus in decision-making (for 1 group) n Challenged each other on decisions/assumptions of documenting n

Advantages & Disadvantages of Medium n n n n Context & direct contact with Advantages & Disadvantages of Medium n n n n Context & direct contact with informants makes it more powerful Some people more inclined to participate Storytelling conflict vs. Non violent communication More time-consuming than other media Consequences of manipulation large Team-work Getting about